A whimsical and serene illustration of a brown-haired woman making a soil mix, shoveling rich, dark soil into a wheelbarrow. She is surrounded by thriving garden beds filled with lush plants and flowers. Soft sunlight casts a warm glow over the earthy textures, creating a peaceful and inviting atmosphere. This scene represents how to make your own seed starting soil, emphasizing the connection between the gardener and the natural process of preparing healthy soil for planting.

How to Make Your Own Seed Starting Soil

February 27, 20253 min read

How to Make Your Own Seed Starting Soil

A whimsical and serene illustration of a brown-haired woman making a soil mix, shoveling rich, dark soil into a wheelbarrow. She is surrounded by thriving garden beds filled with lush plants and flowers. Soft sunlight casts a warm glow over the earthy textures, creating a peaceful and inviting atmosphere. This scene represents how to make your own seed starting soil, emphasizing the connection between the gardener and the natural process of preparing healthy soil for planting.

I notice lots of gardeners stressing over soil when they start their seeds. They spend TONS of money or make crazy complicated mixes that aren’t necessary. I’m going to simplify it for you here in this post. It’s not hard. Seedlings have very basic needs! Here’s how to make your own seed-starting soil without breaking the bank.

Your seedlings need:

  1. Well-draining soil so their roots don’t rot

  2. Fine soil so their roots can grow and expand easily

  3. Well-balanced, light nutrients to avoid burning baby roots or causing massive growth spurts that hurt the longevity of the plant

How Can You Make Your Own Seed Starting Soil?

You should be amending your soil between every planting season. For me, that means a fresh layer of compost, a dusting of seaweed powder or bone meal, and a sprinkle of powdered eggshells. 

Over time the nutrients and soil volume break down. This amending process keeps everything topped off. Right before you amend is the time to make your seed starting soil.

You’ll need a soil sifter for this process. You can make one yourself super easily with some ¼ inch hardware cloth and a piece of 1x2 wood. Just frame up a rectangle and staple the hardware cloth onto it. I use two layers of hardware cloth to make the holes even smaller. Remember, you want fine soil!

Homemade soil sifter resting on a blue wheelbarrow, used for filtering compost and soil in a backyard garden with raised beds in the background.

Sifting Your Seed Starting Soil

The base of my seed starting soil recipe is my old garden bed soil. 

This is perfect from a nutrient standpoint because it’s not totally spent (because I amend my soil regularly) but it has been used for a round of crops so it’s not really hot either. As I said above, seedlings don’t like too many nutrients! It’s easy to burn those tiny root hairs and stunt future growth. 

However, just using raw garden soil won’t work well because it’s not fine enough. This is where your sifter comes in. I take a couple of scoops of soil out of each of my garden beds and sift them into the wheelbarrow. I toss what doesn’t go through the sifter back into the beds. I have about 25 beds so I don’t need to take a lot from each. 

It’s okay if you only have a few beds and you need to take a lot of soil from each one! Just scoop from the edges so you don’t disturb any existing plants. You’ll fill it back in when you amend. 

A hand holding freshly sifted compost, showing rich organic material after being screened for a fine, even texture.

Creating Your Seed Starting Mix

Once you have a wheelbarrow full of sifted seed starting soil it’s time to mix in the vermiculite. I buy mine on Amazon. Don’t get too worried about the perfect mix here! 

Just throw some in there and mix it in. I usually do about 12 cups of vermiculite per wheelbarrow of sifted soil. I mix it with my hands. It feels so good and is super healing. I can feel my nervous system re-setting and grounding as I mix.  

A recycled plastic container filled with vermiculite, a lightweight soil amendment used for improving aeration and moisture retention in gardening.

Storing Your Seed Starting Soil

That’s it! You are done! I just dump the soil into a large tote in my greenhouse and it’s there whenever I need it. Make sure your soil is dry when you store it. If it’s not you can lay it out on a tarp in the sun for a day or two. If you put wet soil in a tote and put a lid on it, you will come back to a mess of mold and it will be a total waste. 

Okay so before you go let’s recap in a quick easy list.

Seed Starting Soil Recipe:

  1. One wheelbarrow of sifted garden soil

  2. 12 Cups of vermiculite

Mix and store somewhere dry.

A close-up of a hand holding seed-starting soil mix, featuring compost, perlite, and other organic materials for optimal plant growth.

Infuse a Little Magic

I love to infuse a little practical magic into everything I do in the garden. When I’m mixing the soil with my hands, I’m infusing intentions of health, abundance, and growth into the soil. 

The energy you are in while you are making your seed starting soil is the energy that will be transferred to your seedlings as they grow. 

Ready to plant some seeds? Learn how to start seeds indoors here.


Hi there! I'm Laura, horse care mentor, suburban homesteader, and spiritual momma. I share stories to inspire others to live holistic lives, whether they're nurturing animals, growing a garden, raising babies, or all three. Welcome! I hope as you read you find the inspiration to get your hands dirty. P.S. Antibiotics and vaccines save lives. This is NOT an alt-right, crunchy pipeline situation. All are welcome.

Laura Langfitt

Hi there! I'm Laura, horse care mentor, suburban homesteader, and spiritual momma. I share stories to inspire others to live holistic lives, whether they're nurturing animals, growing a garden, raising babies, or all three. Welcome! I hope as you read you find the inspiration to get your hands dirty. P.S. Antibiotics and vaccines save lives. This is NOT an alt-right, crunchy pipeline situation. All are welcome.

Back to Blog

Become An Insider

Be the first to know about new posts on suburban homesteading, natural horse care, & spiritual motherhood.

Join the Community

Natural Horse Keeping Tips

Modern management is killing our horses. Nature can teach us a better way! Learn, share, and connect with fellow progressive horse owners.

Listen to the Podcast

The Homestead Witch - All Rights Reserved - Terms & Conditions